Garage Door Replacement vs. Repair – When to Invest in a New Door

Garage Door Installation, Repairs & parts in Kent, Washington

Garage doors are a crucial part of your home, protecting your belongings and providing security. They are a significant investment and can last for many years with proper care and maintenance. However, like any mechanical system, garage doors may require repairs or even replacement from time to time. 

Deciding whether to repair or replace your garage door depends on several factors, including the age of your door, its condition, and the cost of repairs. Before investing in a new garage door, here are a few factors to consider.

When to Repair A Garage Door

If your garage door is experiencing minor issues, it may be possible to repair it instead of replacing it entirely. The following are some common scenarios where a repair may be the best option:

Minor Damage:

If your garage door has minor damage, such as a few dents or scratches, it can typically be repaired without replacing the entire door. An experienced garage door technician can fix dents and restore your door’s appearance to its original state.

Broken Springs:

Garage door springs are essential components that help lift and lower the door. If your garage door is not functioning correctly, it may be due to broken springs. Replacing your garage door springs is relatively inexpensive and a great way to extend the life of your door. Clopay recommends replacing springs every 7 Years or 10,000 cycles.

Sensor Issues:

Garage door sensors prevent the door from closing if an object or person is in its path. If your sensors are not working correctly, it can cause your door to malfunction causing damage to your vehicle or injury to those living under your roof. Repairing or replacing sensors can help ensure the safety of your family and property.

When to Replace a Garage Door

While repairs can be a cost-effective solution in the short term, there may come a time when replacement is necessary. The following are some scenarios where replacing your garage door may be the most cost-efficient option:


Depending on how well it has been maintained, the average lifespan of a garage door is about 15 to 20 years. If your door is nearing the end of its lifespan or has exceeded it, it may be time for a replacement. Old doors can be unreliable and pose a safety risk.

Cost of Repairs:

If your garage door requires frequent repairs, investing in a new one may be more cost-effective. Repairs can add up quickly, and if the cost of repairs exceeds the price of a new door, replacement may be the best option.

Severely Damaged:

If your garage door has severe damage due to an accident or natural disaster, it may not be repairable. Replacement is the only option in cases of large dents, cracks, or broken panels.

Safety and Security:

If your garage door malfunctions, it can pose a safety hazard to your family and property. A faulty door can also compromise the security of your home, leaving it vulnerable to theft and break-ins. Replacing your garage door with a newer, safer, and more secure model can provide you with peace of mind.

Need some Advice?

Whether you’re looking to repair your garage door or install a whole new system, Doorman Service Co is here to help! For over 40 years, we have provided residents of the Greater Puget Sound with first-class garage door service. If you have any questions about door repair or need help choosing a new unit for your home or business, please don’t hesitate to give us a call.

Like this article?

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Linkdin
Share on Pinterest
Scroll to Top